Wayfarer Bread & Pastry
Our pickIn 2017, Crystal White moved to San Diego with a plan for her own bakery and eight Lodge cast-iron pots. She'd grown up in Napa, co-founded Proof Bakery in Los Angeles, and eventually ran the bread department at San Francisco's Tartine Bakery. Here she started small, baking loaves in those cast-iron combo cookers for pop-ups at local cafes. In 2018 she found a storefront on La Jolla Boulevard in Bird Rock, two blocks from the beach, and today Wayfarer Bread & Pastry has more than 25 employees and serves up to 400 people a day.
It's the best bakery in San Diego because it does both halves of the job at the same level. The bread is naturally fermented: a classic sourdough loaf, a multiseed version packed with sesame, flax, sunflower and pumpkin seeds, and a crisp, crunchy baguette. The pastry side is just as strong. Fans of the place put the croissants and the kouign-amann among the best in town. If you haven't met one, a kouign-amann is a Breton pastry with butter and sugar folded into the layers and baked until the sugar caramelizes. Order it first.
The menu moves every week. Wayfarer's motto is Quality over Convenience, and it bakes with organic flour, eggs and dairy and works with local farms, so the seasonal pastries follow what's growing (a plum hazelnut croissant turned up on a recent menu). English muffins are griddled in clarified butter every day, and afternoon sandwiches are built on seasonal produce. On Friday and Saturday nights, pizza chef Alera Dermody runs pizza night, with farm-driven specials that change monthly. Pizza is preorder only, with no walk-ins.
The line has a reputation, and Wayfarer itself calls it infamous, especially on weekends and holidays. The fix is the preorder system, which opens every Monday for that week and takes orders until 5am on pickup day. It's also the way to guarantee a specific loaf, since the case thins well before closing. Seating is limited and there's no dedicated lot, so look for street parking out front or on the blocks behind, then carry your bag the two blocks to the water.




