Mitch's Seafood
Our pickThe idea for Mitch's Seafood reportedly started on a boat. Mitch Conniff was the executive chef aboard the American Angler, a long-range Baja sportfishing boat co-owned by Brian Kiyohara, and the plan they landed on was simple: a restaurant serving local fish, from local boats, run by local people. It opened in Point Loma in 2008, founded by three longtime San Diego fishing families: Brian and Viola Kiyohara, Randy and Tracy Toussaint, and Conniff himself, a chef whose résumé also includes a stint as sous chef at Jsix.
That origin still decides what lands on the plate. Nearly all the seafood comes from the waters off San Diego and Northern Baja, and most of it is caught by the owners or by fishermen they know personally. The restaurant stands on stilts over the water at the Point Loma Sportfishing dock on Scott Street, on the same spot where an earlier restaurant once stood, and it shares the dock complex with the sportfishing fleet. You're eating lunch at a working harbor, boats and all.
The order is the Fisherman's Stew: fish, shrimp, scallops, clams and mussels with tomato, fennel and saffron, plus garlic bread for the last of the bowl. After that, follow the reviewers, who keep coming back to the grilled octopus, the ceviche and the crab cakes. The fish tacos and sandwiches get plenty of love too, and a mixed seafood platter is the easy answer for a table that can't agree on one thing.
Mitch's takes the top spot because the food would hold up even without the view. Of every restaurant considered for this list, it has the steadiest run of strong recent reviews, and it serves breakfast, lunch and dinner, so it fits almost any plan. Breakfast is the lower-key way in, a separate morning menu to start the day on the dock. There are no reservations: you order at the counter and grab the next open table, inside or out, and at peak times both the line and the seats fill up.



