Skip to content

This weekend: CRSSD Fall · Sat Doors noon both days · Tickets on sale

The San Diego List*
WEEKEND

Local spotlight · San Diego

Andrew Gonzalez, the San Diego Custom Jeweler Who Works One Client at a Time

Thirty years in fine jewelry, stores of his own, and a relaxed, text-first way of building the engagement ring you have been picturing, or one you haven't imagined yet.

By The San Diego List · Sources checked ·

Andrew Gonzalez of Luxury Custom Jeweler, a San Diego custom jeweler, in a black tuxedo and bow tie
Andrew Gonzalez has spent more than thirty years in his family's jewelry business. Photo: Luxury Custom Jeweler · Used with permission

Andrew Gonzalez, the jeweler behind Luxury Custom Jeweler, is a San Diego custom jeweler with more than thirty years in fine jewelry. He designs and builds custom engagement rings, wedding bands and heirloom resets for one client at a time, and most of his clients work with him right from their phones, over text.

Two things come through in everything Andrew does. He is easygoing and casual, the kind of expert who is more interested in what you are hoping for than in making a sales pitch. And he loves this work. Of everything in the jewelry business, building someone's dream engagement ring is the part he never let go of.

Jewelry is his family's business, and it has been his whole working life: owning and managing stores, his own and his family's, buying and selling diamonds and gold wholesale, and building custom pieces. Today he runs Luxury Custom Jeweler with his son, and every client deals with Andrew directly, from the first text to the day the ring goes on a hand.

The rings he is proudest of are the ones he made for his own family: the ring he proposed to his wife with, his daughter's engagement ring, and the one he is building now for his son. You won't find a photo of any of them. Andrew keeps every client's ring just as private, made for one person and never offered up to be copied.

Who
Andrew Gonzalez, founder of Luxury Custom Jeweler
Where
San Diego. In-person viewings downtown at the Jewelers Exchange.
Makes
Custom engagement rings, wedding bands, heirloom resets, anniversary rings, earrings and pendants
Builds
Made to order from a proven design, modified to make it yours, or one of one in CAD
Diamonds
Natural and lab-grown, each one looked at in person before it reaches you
Experience
30+ years in fine jewelry; trained through GIA as an Applied Jewelry Professional
How it starts
A text, then a consultation call about what you want and what he recommends
Timing
Most rings finish in about 14 to 30 days
Works with
San Diego clients and buyers anywhere, mostly over text

Checked

In this story
  1. 01 · What it's like to work with Andrew
  2. 02 · Why so many clients end up with a ring they never expected
  3. 03 · More ring for your budget
  4. 04 · Better diamonds, chosen by eye
  5. 05 · Three ways to build your ring
  6. 06 · How a custom ring comes together
  7. 07 · What he makes
  8. 08 · A family business that grows by referral
  9. 09 · Why people choose Andrew
  10. 10 · How to start
  11. 11 · Questions people ask

What it's like to work with Andrew

Most of the conversation happens over text, at whatever pace suits you. You send the rings you have been saving, ask your questions, react to his ideas, and later look over the stones he has found and the design as it takes shape, all from the same thread. And the replies come from Andrew himself. In his words, "You'll get a reply from me, not a call center."

You don't need to speak jewelry, either. A screenshot and a rough budget are a complete starting point, and so is a list of what you don't like. Plain English is the working language, and translating it into the technical decisions is his job.

The one call that matters is the consultation. You talk through what you are looking for, who the ring is for, how she wears jewelry and the range you have in mind, and Andrew tells you what he would recommend and why. You come off that call with a concrete plan: which stones he will go find, which setting path fits and what the timeline looks like. It is a relaxed conversation with someone who knows the answer to almost every ring question you could ask.

Working this way respects your time. You can plan a ring on your lunch break, from another city or while keeping it a secret from the person it is for. And whenever you would rather look at the stones yourself, he sits down with you downtown at the Jewelers Exchange.

Why so many clients end up with a ring they never expected

Plenty of people come to Andrew knowing exactly what they want, and some leave with exactly that. A lot of them leave with something else entirely, and they are happier for it.

That tends to happen once his expertise enters the conversation. Someone arrives set on a particular shape or setting, and Andrew surprises them with a piece or a design they have never seen. The idea they walked in with becomes a starting point, and the ring they end up with is one they did not know to ask for. Those are the moments that get his clients most excited.

He makes room for that kind of change on purpose. Before a design is approved, changing your mind costs nothing. As he puts it, "a design on paper is cheap to redraw and I'd rather redraw it than build the wrong ring."

Sometimes the change is a small detail with a big payoff. Hannah had been told by two other jewelers that her engagement ring's low setting meant living with a gap next to her wedding band:

"Andrew made one that sits completely flush. It's the detail I didn't know to care about until he explained it."

More ring for your budget

Andrew builds fine jewelry, and his prices reflect the quality of the stones and the craftsmanship. Where he stands out is value. For a comparable ring, his pricing is much more competitive than what you would typically find at a jewelry store, because the costs of running a store are never built into your ring.

Years of owning stores taught him exactly where that money goes. He knows "how pieces are priced, how stores mark them up, and where the money should actually go when someone wants a serious custom ring." A retail ring carries the room, the staff, the security and a case of unsold inventory. None of that exists at Luxury Custom Jeweler, so your money goes into the diamond, the metal and the hours it takes to build.

He is happy to prove it. Bring any written quote, from a store or a website, and he will put his number next to it on the same specifications.

The bigger difference is the advice. Andrew carries no inventory, works on no commission and has no case of rings he needs to move, so there is no particular stone he needs you to buy. His pricing page opens with a line that sums up the whole approach: "Nothing here needs to be sold to you." That frees him to be consultative: to help you find the ring you are after at a great price, and to show you when a smarter option gets you more for the same money. Veronica's husband worked with him on earrings for their twentieth anniversary, and when one design was going to run over budget, "Andrew just said so and showed us a smarter way to get the same look."

Priya, who bought a radiant-cut engagement ring, put it this way:

"He put two diamonds with nearly identical reports under the loupe and showed me exactly why the cheaper one wasn't the better deal. I have never had anyone in a sales situation talk me out of spending money before."

Better diamonds, chosen by eye

Big retailers buy diamonds by the hundred and need them consistent and available. Andrew buys for one ring at a time, from brokers he has bought from for thirty years, which means he can afford to be picky and turn down twenty diamonds before one is good enough. As he explains it, cutters and dealers know that, so the best stones get shown to jewelers like him first. Your diamond might come from New York, from London or from closer to home.

Then he looks at every one himself. Andrew trained through GIA as an Applied Jewelry Professional, and what that training sharpens is the part a grading report leaves out: whether a stone is lively or dull, whether it was cut to sparkle or cut to keep weight, and where a flaw sits. An inclusion tucked near the edge can disappear under a prong for life. The same size inclusion under the table, the big flat facet on top, is the one he says "can catch your eye every time you look down on your stone." He lays out how he reads a stone in his diamond study.

He works with natural and lab-grown diamonds and has no stake in which you choose. He will put the two side by side in the same shape and budget and let your own eyes decide.

Miguel and Sofia came to him with a listing from one of the big diamond websites. Andrew sourced a diamond with the same specs, and when they compared the close-up video from the online listing with his stone in person, his was noticeably better. His number was lower, too.

Three ways to build your ring

Custom can mean a few different things, and Andrew does all of them. After the consultation, you get a written plan that says which one your ring needs.

Made to order. A proven design, built brand new for you around the diamond he selected.

Modified. A style you already love, adjusted until it is yours: a different setting, a wider band, a lower profile, new details along the sides.

One of one. When the ring you want does not exist yet, he designs it from scratch in CAD, computer-aided design software that builds a precise 3D model of your ring around the measurements of your actual stone. You review the model from the top and in profile, ask for changes as many times as it takes, and nothing gets made until you sign off. The design you approve is the ring that gets built.

Andrew calls CAD "a tool, not an upsell." If your ring does not need it, he will tell you, and there is no design fee added to a ring that doesn't need one. If you want a head start, his design directions page is a good place to find a style to react to.

How a custom ring comes together

  1. Send a text. A photo of a ring you like, a rough budget and your timing are plenty to start.
  2. Have the consultation call. You talk through what you are looking for, and Andrew tells you what he recommends.
  3. Get your plan in writing. How the ring will be built, what the diamond search will target and what it all means for your number, before any deposit.
  4. Choose your stone. Andrew sends his shortlist as photos and video shot the way he is looking at them, with his read on every one in plain words. Most clients choose right from their phones. Once you have chosen, a deposit under a short written contract lets him order your diamond.
  5. Approve the design. The setting is selected, modified or designed around your stone, you sign off, and the ring goes into production. The balance is due before it is finished.

Most rings finish in about 14 to 30 days. If there is a proposal date, he plans backward from it so the ring is ready when you are.

If you want to get ready before that first text, his engagement ring buying checklist covers what to have in hand, and the full process is laid out on his how it works page.

What he makes

Most of his work is custom engagement rings and the wedding bands that go with them, including bands shaped to sit flush against an engagement ring, and men's bands built for decades of daily wear.

He also resets family diamonds into rings people will wear every day, returning the original mounting to you. He builds rings from a photo, designs anniversary bands, eternity rings and upgrades around the set already on her hand, and makes earrings, pendants and one-of-one pieces for gifts, milestones or no occasion at all. Found a ring online? Send him the listing before you buy, and he will tell you what the stone and setting really are and how to get that look built properly. Derek and Lauren brought him a grandmother's diamond:

"He handled it like it was his own family's stone, and he returned the old setting in a little pouch, which meant the world to my mom."

Whatever the piece, the standard is lasting quality and a professional finish, the kind of ring built to be worn every day for the next fifty years.

A family business that grows by referral

Luxury Custom Jeweler is a father-and-son business. Andrew handles the diamonds and the design, and his son runs the marketing and everything online. There are no investors, no sales floor and nobody whose paycheck depends on talking you into a bigger stone. The person who quotes your ring is the person who finds the stone, builds the ring and answers for it afterward.

Most of his clients arrive because someone he built a ring for sent them, and other jewelers call him when they need a stone found. Andrew has done business in San Diego's jewelry world his whole life, and people there know him by name. He likes to say he will treat you like family, the good side of family, which in practice means straight answers, honest advice and a number in writing. And he will be there next year, for the wedding band and whatever comes after it.

Why people choose Andrew

  • One expert from start to finish. The person you text is the person who picks the stone, plans the ring and hands it to you.
  • A better diamond for the money. Stones sourced for your ring alone and judged by eye, with no showroom inside the price.
  • A ring you might not have imagined. Thirty years of design experience, and the freedom to change your mind before anything is made.
  • No pressure, ever. No inventory, no commission and no quota, so the advice is about your ring and nothing else.
  • Everything in writing. A written plan and a real number before any deposit, and a design you approve before production.
  • Easy from anywhere. Most of the ring happens over text, whether you live in San Diego or across the country.

How to start

Text a photo of a ring you like to (619) 279-7738, along with a rough budget, any date you are working toward and whether you are thinking natural, lab-grown or both. If the proposal is a surprise, say so. Andrew will reply himself and set up the consultation call, and from there you will know exactly what your number can build.

Questions people ask

Who is Andrew Gonzalez?

Andrew Gonzalez is a San Diego custom jeweler and the founder of Luxury Custom Jeweler. He has more than thirty years in his family's jewelry business, including owning and managing stores, and he trained through GIA as an Applied Jewelry Professional.

What is Luxury Custom Jeweler?

Luxury Custom Jeweler is Andrew Gonzalez's private custom jewelry business in San Diego, which he runs with his son. It designs and builds custom engagement rings, wedding bands, heirloom resets and anniversary pieces, with every diamond sourced for one client.

Where is Luxury Custom Jeweler located?

Luxury Custom Jeweler is based in San Diego. Most clients work with Andrew over text after a consultation call, and if you want to see stones in person, he sits down with you downtown at the Jewelers Exchange.

Is Luxury Custom Jeweler expensive?

Andrew builds fine jewelry, and his prices reflect the quality of the diamond and the craftsmanship. For a comparable ring, his pricing is much more competitive than a typical jewelry store's, because there is no showroom or retail inventory built into the price. He designs to the budget you give him, and he will put his number next to any written quote on the same specifications.

Can Andrew design a one-of-one engagement ring?

Yes. He designs fully custom rings in CAD, a precise 3D model built around your actual stone that you approve before anything is made. He also builds proven designs to order and modifies existing styles when that is the better path.

How long does a custom engagement ring take?

Most of Andrew's rings finish in about 14 to 30 days. If there is a proposal date, he plans backward from it.

Do I need to meet Andrew in person?

No. Most of his clients work with him over text, with one consultation call to go over what they want and what he recommends. Seeing stones in person is available whenever you want it.

How do I contact Andrew Gonzalez?

Text or call (619) 279-7738, or reach him through luxurycustomjeweler.com. Texting a photo of a ring you like, along with what you want to spend, is the fastest way to start.

Sources & updates

Something changed? Send a correction.

Your next good San Diego plan.

Places to try, weekend ideas and the local updates that change your plans. Join the early list. We’ll email you when the first issue launches.

By subscribing, you agree to receive The Shortlist by email when it launches. Free; unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy. Questions about The Shortlist?