Skip to content

This weekend: CRSSD Fall · Sat Doors noon both days · Tickets on sale

The San Diego List*
WEEKEND

Local spotlight · San Diego

Andrew Gonzalez, the San Diego Jeweler Who Sees What the Diamond Report Doesn't

We talked with Andrew Gonzalez about diamonds, engagement rings, and why a grading report is only the beginning.

By The San Diego List · Sources checked ·

Andrew Gonzalez of Luxury Custom Jeweler, a San Diego jeweler, in a black tuxedo and bow tie
Andrew Gonzalez has spent more than thirty years in the jewelry business. Photo: Luxury Custom Jeweler · Used with permission

Andrew Gonzalez has spent more than thirty years in the jewelry business in San Diego. He owned his own jewelry store, and today he manages another. Every week he also buys and sells diamonds wholesale. Through Luxury Custom Jeweler, he does the work he loves most: helping people build an engagement ring from scratch, starting with the diamond. When we talked with him, the diamond is where the conversation kept coming back.

Who
Andrew Gonzalez, Luxury Custom Jeweler
Where
San Diego
Specialty
Engagement rings built from scratch around a hand-selected diamond
Diamonds
Natural and lab-grown, each evaluated by eye beyond its grading report
Experience
30+ years in the jewelry business; owned his own store and manages another today; GIA Applied Jewelry Professional (AJP)
Works with
Clients across San Diego and beyond, mostly by text

Checked

In this story
  1. 01 · "Reports alone don't tell you"
  2. 02 · "I'm buying where jewelers buy"
  3. 03 · Built from scratch, around the diamond
  4. 04 · "The person you hired"
  5. 05 · Getting in touch

"Reports alone don't tell you"

Diamonds are sold everywhere now, from online listings to TikTok livestreams, and plenty of buyers pick one based on its grading report. Andrew doesn't dismiss the report. He reads every one. But for him, it's where the work starts, not where it ends.

"Reports alone don't tell you which stone deserves her hand," he says. It's the reason he earned GIA's Applied Jewelry Professional (AJP) credential, and it's clearly the part of the job he loves explaining.

A report records carat weight, color and clarity, plus a cut grade for round diamonds. What it leaves out is much of what you actually see. It doesn't grade haziness, which can make a stone look flat. It tells you a diamond has inclusions but not where they sit. One tucked near the edge can hide under a prong for life. The same flaw in the center, he says, "can catch your eye every time you look down at your stone." And ovals, pears, emeralds, cushions and other fancy shapes get no cut grade at all, even though cut decides how much a diamond sparkles.

So Andrew looks at every candidate stone himself. Clients get photos and video of each one, with the report beside it and his read on it in plain language, so they can see the difference instead of taking it on faith. His guide to what a diamond report won't tell you goes deeper.

"I'm buying where jewelers buy"

Part of what makes that possible is where Andrew sits in the business. Buying and selling diamonds wholesale gives him a steady view of stones most shoppers never see, and a trained sense of what each one is worth.

"Buying and selling those stones is what I do all week," he says. "I'm not ordering from a catalog. I'm buying where jewelers buy."

That lets him be picky on a client's behalf, passing on stone after stone until the right one comes along. He works with natural and lab-grown diamonds and has no stake in which one you choose.

Built from scratch, around the diamond

Of everything in the jewelry business, custom work is what he calls "the part I never let go of," and engagement rings most of all. His specialty is building the ring from scratch around the diamond. First he learns who it's for and how they wear jewelry. Then he designs the ring in CAD, a precise 3D model sized to the actual stone. He calls CAD "a tool, not an upsell." Nothing gets made until the client signs off, and changes along the way are welcome.

"A design on paper is cheap to redraw," he says, "and I'd rather redraw it than build the wrong ring."

The finished pieces stay private. Andrew doesn't keep a public gallery of client rings. As he puts it, "What I make for you stays yours."

"The person you hired"

What stood out most in talking with Andrew is how little he sounds like a salesman. He's relaxed and direct, happy to explain anything, and he designs to the budget you give him instead of pushing past it.

"My job is to be the person you hired, not the brand you walked into," he says. In practice, that means a written plan and a real number before any deposit, and replies from Andrew himself: "You'll get a reply from me, not a call center." It also means honesty when it costs him the sale. Bring him a quote from somewhere else, and he'll compare it on the same specifications. "If their deal is genuinely better, I'll tell you to take it."

It's easy to see why most of his clients find him the same way: someone he made a ring for sent them.

Getting in touch

Andrew works with clients across San Diego and beyond, mostly by text. A photo of a ring you love, a rough budget and any date you're working toward are enough to start. Text or call (619) 279-7738, or visit luxurycustomjeweler.com.

Sources & updates

Something changed? Send a correction.

Your next good San Diego plan.

Places to try, weekend ideas and the local updates that change your plans. Join the early list. We’ll email you when the first issue launches.

By subscribing, you agree to receive The Shortlist by email when it launches. Free; unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy. Questions about The Shortlist?